[fabsroman]

Okay, I now have a headache.

Yes, in a perfect world, the shooter would know his rifle in and out and always make the perfect shot with the perfect deer rifle. Oh yeah, the world isn't perfect.

If it were, we wouldn't have to worry about somebody misjudging distance or the ability of the gun. We would never have to worry about a complete miss because all the shots would be spine or neck shots that are instantaneously deadly.

I agree with one other post. Trying to argue about which deer cartridge is the best is ridiculous. The only question is whether or not the cartridge can get the job done for the person shooting the gun.