View Single Post
  #9  
Old 05-23-2011, 09:25 PM
fabsroman's Avatar
fabsroman fabsroman is offline
Moderator
 
Join Date: Nov 2001
Location: Maryland
Posts: 7,823
Quote:
Originally Posted by Mr. 16 gauge View Post
Sorry, but I disagree with most of the posts here.

This story originally broke years ago, as the man in question (Demanjuk (sp?)) lived in the town right next to me ....literally. He is not accused of 'just being a guard'....he is accused of crimes against humanity, including torture and MURDER!!! Lasts time I heard, there was no statute of limitations on murder.
...and, if it was YOUR family members who were murdered, wouldn't you want justice for their killer(s)? Would you let them get away with it, just because they were 'old', or 'just in the wrong place at the wrong time'? I don't buy into the idea that they "had to do it, or else they would face the same treatment"....there were plenty of guards in camps that weren't sadists and murders. Just because this individual managed to hide it so well for all these years doesn't mean he should get a free pass.

Small cog in the machine? Maybe so, but that 'small cog' kept all the big cogs moving....

It's unfortunate that the U.S. must share the blame in some of this.....look into Japan's unit 731 in Manchuria and see the atrocities that they committed in the name of 'scientific research' (if you can stomach it....I work in an O.R. and after seeing/reading some of the things these animals did, I thought I was going to barf.....I had to quit reading half way through). Not only did they commit their atrocities on (primarily) Chinese citizens, but American POWs as well....and our country gave them a 'free pass' in order to get a look at the 'data' because of the cold war. Many of these sadists (er....excuse me, researchers) went on to become prominent politicians, presidents of Universities, heads of industry, ect.....and NONE of them EVER admitted to their crimes. And Japan, as a nation, has never acknowledged the fact that Unit 731 ever existed.
Should we just give them a free pass? After all, they are all old as well.....

Oh, and by the way: Unit 731 also experimented with "balloon bombs" to try and spread biological and chemical weapons over the United States. Little know fact: about 200 of these bombs reached the U.S., and one killed 7 people, including a woman who was 8 months pregnant.
....but let's just give them a free pass; after all, the war was over 60 years ago, and these were just civilians that they made war on....

I've seen other posts on here with re: to crime, criminals 'getting away with murder' because of legal issues filed by the ACLU, ect. You guys get pretty pissed off when you feel that justice is stymied. Yet here you are, doing the same thing because the guy is "old" and "the war was a long time ago".

The smell of hypocrisy is rather rank today....................
It is all in the eyes of the beholder. Ever stop to think that we dropped 2 atomic bombs on Japan and killed thousands of civilians? That sounds like a war crime to me. How about the fire bombing of Dresden? That one sounds like an atrocity to me too. People will argue that it was done to completely demoralize the Germans, but IMO the war was already over and it wasn't needed.

Didn't we round up Japanese civilians and put them behind fences. Granted, nothing like the German camps or the way the Japanese treated POWs.

Then, you have to keep in mind that the history of wars is usually written by the victors.

Got into it on another chatboard with a Canadian that felt Canada did more in WWII than the US. I guess that is how a Canadian would view it through Canadian eyes.

Finally, I do think the guy was a small cog in a really big machine. If a soldier is given an order to kill civilians, or even torture them, what is that soldier to do. Just look at the US and waterboarding. Let's not even get into the crap that happens at Guantanomo. Not that I completely disagree with it, but just because we might have to court martial a lot more Americans and send the President to prison too.

We happen to be the "good guys" in WWII because we won.
__________________
The pond, waterfowl, and yellow labs...it don't get any better.
Reply With Quote