Deer Rifle for Police Sniper

[Aim to maim]

A buddy of mine who is an extensively trained and proficient police department designated SWAT sniper has recently discovered deer hunting and is hooked on it. It has not taken him long to realize that his department issue heavy barrel Remington 700, while highly effective, is a bit cumbersome and heavy.

He is contemplating the purchase of his own bolt action rifle, probably in 30-06, .270 or .308. As is the case with most police officers, he is not rich, so cost is an object. Currently in the running are a Remington 710/ Bushnell scope package for $219 and a Mossberg ATR for $289 (both NIB).

I realize, as does he, that the Bushnell scope in question is essentially a throwaway. I have seen the Remington 710 bashed extensively on this and other sights, but very few specifics (especially based on user experience) as to why it is so universally despised.

As for the Mossberg, the prospective buyer duck hunts with a Mossberg shotgun and carries another one in his police vehicle. He is impressed with the reliability and durability of both of them. He is a bit cautious, however, because the ATR rifle could be considered a new and unproven product.

I know, as does he, that a Remington 700 is certainly superior to the Remington 710 and probably to the Mossberg ATR, but I’d be interested in some specific reasons why, FOR THE PURPOSE OF SHOOTING WHITETAIL DEER AT 50 TO 200 YARDS , the Remington 700 is worth the premium price.

Feel free to suggest alternatives, and if you are compelled to respond that one or the other is a piece of $&*@ , please elaborate with some specific information.